Tuesday, 8 December 2015

Independent Review Panel Mechanism

Independent Review 

On 13 May, 2014 the Government decided that the Minister for Justice and Equality, in consultation with the Attorney General, should establish an Independent Review Mechanism to consider allegations of Garda misconduct or inadequacies in the investigation of such allegations, with a view to determining to what extent and in what manner further action may be required in each case. This was one of the actions agreed by Government as a response to the Guerin report.
A panel consisting of two Senior and five Junior Counsel, all selected on the basis of their experience of the criminal justice system, was established for the purpose. The complaints were in the form of letters, some of which have been sent by the individuals direct, while others had been submitted through intermediaries, such as TDs or representative organisations. They arose from a wide variety of situations.
The review of each allegation consisted of an examination of the papers by a counsel from the Panel, and did not involve interviews or interaction with complainants or any other form of investigation, although counsel could recommend that the Minister seek further information to assist in coming to an appropriate recommendation in any particular case. The purpose of the review was to triage the allegations to see if further investigations are needed.
While the volume and complexity of cases has led to the review taking longer than originally anticipated, the Panel has provided recommendations to the Minister in all 320 cases submitted to them and has therefore largely concluded its work.
The Minister is mindful that all complainants are anxious to know the outcome of the review of their case and every effort is being made to conclude the process.  In each case a submission will be prepared. Mr Justice Roderick Murphy will review the summary of the conclusion and the letter of notification drafted, to ensure that they are a fair and accurate reflection of the recommendation.
The issuing of notification letters to complainants commenced on 29 June. 

Letters will continue to issue to all complainants until the process is completed.

 It is the Minister’s intention, on the completion of the process, to make a comprehensive statement on all the actions she has decided to take in line with the recommendations of counsel. 
While it would not be appropriate to publish individual recommendations, the Minister has considered how best information on the outcome of this process could be made public.  

In this regard, the Minister has asked counsel, in addition to making recommendations in individual cases, to produce a general overview Report of the issue and trends identified through this process.  This Report will inform consideration of any changes which may be necessary to ensure that similar issues do not arise in future. The Minister has indicated that she will publish this Report

Data Protection Act

Did you know?
You can request your Garda Files using the Data Protection Act?
Here's what to do.
Write to:
Data protection Officer.Garda data processing unit.
Racecourse Road,Thurles ,County Tipp.
Here is how you have to word the letter.
Dear Data Protection Officer under the data protection act 1988-2003 I wish to make access for copies to all data you hold on me on computer or in manual form. My date of birth is _____ .Enclosed with my application there is an Irish money order for E6.35 and a copy of my ID or birth cert.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
When you write this letter make two copies of your money order and letter to the data protection officer.
You will need these later on in the process, so keep a copy of them.
You will receive a letter back saying they got your application and are working on it. You may not hear from them again .So 40 days after making the application make two complaints .One to the data protection commissioner and another complaint to the garda ombudsman. Do not call the garda data protection office when you do not hear from them.
Enclose your copy of the letter and the money order you originally sent to the Garda Data Protection Office.
If you have had a case sent off to the DPP by the Garda you can also request that file using the data protection act to get them. If you want them. You will also need a money order for them too.
If anyone does use this service please let me know how they got on, see the below link also.

Sunday, 6 September 2015

UPDATE 6 SEPTEMBER 2015

UPDATE:

Sorry I haven't posted for such a long time, was trying to prepare for a meeting with the Garda and had to get so much paper work ready. 

We met on Friday 28/08/15 and had a 10 hour meeting, over all I was happy enough with it, even though we only got through half the papers and now have to meet again, but in all I think it is going in the right direction and I really cant say much more than that at this time.

Hubby and I were married 21 years on 17th August, and our son turned 28 the next day so we had lots to celebrate. 

I am still waiting to hear from the Department of Justice about the Panel Review and if my case has been chosen to be heard by a Commission, it if was, it means I can summons "witnesses" to give evidence which means I can call the men who abused me, and the cops who worked on my daughters murder case. 

I could also call family members who protected the paedophiles in my family and in the village of Dalkey and establish if some of my older sisters are receiving silence money.



Cynthia Owen 

Saturday, 13 June 2015

Update (13th June 2015)

Sorry I have not been posting much recently have been busy moving house and supporting hubby in his recovery and trying to finish my studies. I am now delighted to report I have earned a 2.2 BA Honours Degree in Social Sciences and I will post more about this achievement once I graduate in July.

Still no word from the Police (well only to say they are nearly finished their investigations) and still no word from the Panel Review, but recent media reports suggests we should begin hearing very soon.

There are now 365 cases of Garda Corruption to be looked at, will the government finally become  transparent or will they carry on their tradition of betraying and ignoring us? We will have to wait and see................................

For myself I swing between "surely to God they won't be that stupid to ignore such a huge divide between victim and oppressor, with elections coming up, they have no choice but to put this right" to.... "dont be ridiculous you have been on this campaign for 22 years and nothing has EVER changed over that time, still the same old, same old, covering their backs theory and brushing it all under the carpet"

One thing I do know is that the waiting has nearly  killed me, coming up to a year now, to hear from the panel review with little or no information from them to help me along the journey, despite my solicitor and I writing to them with several queries over that time. And waiting for the police to complete for the last 18 months or so, and the trauma it caused me assisting both the Minister for Justice and the police having to go over it over and over again, is NEVER worth the trauma I suffer and never justifies the outcome which is usually a big fat nothing.

The last 18 months have also been very difficult for hubby as we battled through his cancer, feeling scared, alone and isolated, almost in a dream like state with every day feeling like a nightmare, we were surrounded by friends and loved ones and the support was outstanding, but it didn't stop us feeling terrified and anxious and scared. The whole process knocked us both for six and is still on-going.

On top of that I had my degree to finish,  I was  supposed to have finished in June 2014, to Graduate in July 2014, but I had to put it on hold due to the trauma from assisting the police, telling myself it would be worth it. I just could not manage both, but a whole year later I am still waiting and still traumatised every day as I wait to hear big news and wake each day with it on my mind, this doesn't feel any different to me than the usual waiting game that normally comes to nothing and no real answers or no real recognition or acknowledgement or apology. Lets hope I am wrong.

I intend to eventually blog on a more regular basis and in time I intend to put up extracts from my book that I wasn't allowed to publish for legal reasons, this has always rankled me, while I completely understood that the publishers had to protect themselves and given that I have been legally threatened a few times, I was happy to accept their worries.

However somewhere down the line if I ever get the time I intend to tell my full story on here if I can't get to tell it in a courtroom or an inquiry  and I intend to name all the men responsible so watch this space............................



~Thank you

Thursday, 5 March 2015

SOME MORE POSITIVE NEWS:


SOME MORE  POSITIVE NEWS:

I am delighted to announce that Simon got the all - clear today from Prostate Cancer. Simon was very young to have had prostate cancer, it was diagnosed when he was 47, but his symptoms had been present since he was 43. 

Please if you are having any problems with your "water works" see your GP a simple blood test can catch it and studies show that it is a very high success rate if caught early enough. 

Men whose father or brother had prostate cancer are two and a half times more likely to have prostate cancer and men who have prostrate cancer their sisters are at risk of getting breast cancer so please get yourselves to the GP and don't leave it too late. 

Thankfully Simon is now in a low risk grade and will be checked every three months for the next five years. We certainly were very lucky, as we caught it on time. Will you?

Thursday, 19 February 2015

Some positive news!!!!!

URGENT POSITIVE NEWS!!!!!!!
Received this tonight as I logged on after midnight but wanted to share its quite "hopeful" and I am surprised they even replied to me! This is very positive news for my case, and I may very well end up getting the inquiry I have always wanted in that I will be able to put the men who abused me on the stand, okay so it wont be a criminal trial, but, they will be summonsed to attend and will face legal consequences if they don't.
However, please do continue to email the Minister and her Department and insist my case is looked at by a Commission its very important to put pressure on her office, thanks.
Email: info@justice.ie and show your support for Justice for Noleen.
Minister's Reference: 0819100447 IRM Reference: 4/500/1/171
Dear Ms. Owen,
I am directed by the Minister for Justice and Equality, Ms Frances Fitzgerald, T.D. to refer to your open letter of 22 December, 2014 expressing concern that none of the matters being considered by the panel of counsel operating the Independent Review Mechanism were included in the terms of reference for the Commission of Investigation set up as a result of the recommendations of the Guerin Report.
The delay in responding is regretted. This independent review panel has been examining 315 cases referred to them. This is a significant number of cases, and somewhat higher than originally estimated.
This has meant that the review has taken longer than originally expected, as it was not thought right to place a time constraint on the review. It is important for every case to be considered properly especially as the cases contain a very wide variety in the type and seriousness of the allegations.
Counsel are however making every effort to conclude their work as soon is reasonably practicable. It is open to the panel of counsel operating the review mechanism to make recommendations as they see fit in relation to each case. Where counsel do recommend further investigations, the Minister has clearly stated that she will be very strongly guided by that advice.
There are a number of possible options for further investigations. The Minister has stated that any recommendation for referral of a case to a commission of investigation will be very carefully considered. Such investigation could be arranged either by way of amending the terms of reference of an existing commissionor the establishment of a separate commission.
I hope that this explanation is of assistance. I will write to you again once the Minister has received and considered counsel’s recommendations. Yours sincerely,
Chris Quattrociocchi

Tuesday, 10 February 2015

Nearly that time of year again!

NOLEEN'S 42nd ANNIVERSARY:

I cannot believe that we are fast approaching Noleen's 42nd Anniversary on 4/4/2015. I set this blog up in January 2013, in the run up to Noleen's 40th Anniversary, little did I know I would be changing the blog title as each year passes. So soon the link to the blog will be www.noleenbetrayed42years.blogspot.com

Already the daffodils are out and spring is in the year as we creep through February and my sister Theresa's 10th Anniversary, on the 23rd February she would have been 43 had she lived,  I am not sure yet if I will mark her anniversary on my Facebook page (DalkeySindyMurphy) as I have so    much to cope with right now.

Simon has had his operation to remove his prostrate and we are just waiting on the biopsy to see if he is now cancer free, he is not home a week yet, from the hospital, depending on how things go, I may just spend Theresa's anniversary quietly with my daughter in law, and go somewhere beautiful and scenic to think of her.

I am waiting on so much news from Ireland too, which I have asked my solicitor to put on  hold while I help Simon recover from  his operation, so lets see how things go.

This year for Noleens anniversary we are going to visit our Niece, so can spend it with family, instead of my usual pilgrimage to Ireland to keep Noleens name in the media I am going to spend it at home with my 9 year old niece whom I love to bits and her parents. It will be nice to be around children and to laugh and feel free from shackles of guilt that usually torment me every year and send me to Ireland to do press conferences or memorial masses to keep her name alive.

However it will still be a sad and painful time, and to make it worse I will be visiting a town where Theresa and I lived together for four years, and where I first found the courage to tell someone in Authority about Noleen, that will bring its own challenges,  but I will face them and use the time to quietly spend time with people who love me and care about me.

My heart is already aching as I prepare mentally now to wake up on 4/4/2015 the 42nd anniversary of my beautiful little baby who was born and murdered on that day, already the pain has begun. The daffodils always mark the start of this time for me, as they were in bloom all around me when Noleen died and are always a constant reminder for me, I always fill the house with them at this time of year.

As soon as I see them in the shops I enter into a mourning period that starts earlier and earlier each year as we get milder winters.

And so the long painful journey to 4/4/2015 begins.....................................

Wednesday, 31 December 2014

Goodbye 2014!!!!!!

Goodbye 2014!!!!! Okay, so its time to say goodbye to 2014, and what a year. Looking back its been a good year as far as my legal battle has gone. Lots of things happened and there is lots more to come. I have already mentioned this but I will go over it again for those of you who might not know. In January a new police team in Dunlaoghaire headed up by Chief Superintendent Diarmuid O'Sullivan began to re-examine the file , my solicitor worked closely with them and by April and Noleens 41st Anniversary six of the men who abused me (known as the Sorrento Six were interviewed by the police).< On Noleens anniversary a petition with 12,444 signatures was handed in to the Department of Justice demanding that my case be part of The Commission to Investigate into the Guerin Report which was a review of Garda Mishandling and corruption. The Minister for Justice asked for a report into my case and then later on we found out that 305 cases of police corruption and Garda mishandling were submitted to the Department of justice. (This would later become 322 cases). This led to the setting up of a Review Panel of 7 barristers to look at these cases to see if they too could be added to the Guerin Report findings which could mean that our cases went to the Commission to Investigate and would be part of a public inquiry, back to that later. The Sorrento six (Who were dubbed the Sorrento Six by the garda, because they are the six remaining men who abused me in a house on Sorrento Road in Dalkey) were brought in for questioning again and some of their homes searched, one of them was thankfully removed from a large sports club in Dalkey where he had open access to over 200 children, another sacked as a taxi driver and another had to move from his local pub having been a customer there for over 40 years. The net was closing in and finally these men were beginning to be treated as suspects in a murder case and as prolific paedophiles and the risk they posed was finally being taken seriously as was the risk my two brothers posed. The police are still investigating and although it is painfully slow which causes me daily anguish and trauma I am hoping that things will be wrapped up pretty soon, I met with the police for five hours in June and I hope to meet with them again early in the new year. The police are pursuing two new avenues that I cannot reveal just yet but both of them could be the major breakthrough my case needs and could lead to justice. Separately to that, my case could be included in a public inquiry which would mean I could call the men who abused me as witnesses and finally reveal to the world just who they are and what they did to me and the part they played in covering up my daughters murder. The men are still being investigated and can be called back in for questioning at any time, and I'm hoping that one of the avenues the police are pursuing may see them finally prosecuted if all goes well. So in all 2014 was a good year with lots of positive developments in the case and lots of options available and some still available in my quest for justice. As always I was well supported by my friends and the Dalkey girls took a trip to Liverpool to spend quality time together which a great time was had by all! I was delighted to be able to spend time with my childhood friends who have supported me since day 1. I was as always supported by Simon and my immediate family and Simon's family and as most of you know Simon and I renewed our wedding vows in Gretna Green to celebrate 20 years of marriage which was absolutely awesome and wonderful. Not only was I supported by my lifelong friends and my family but as always I was supported by so many of you on Facebook and other members of the public and the regular ongoing messages /letters/texts remind me why I am doing this and give me strength to carry on. I am also supported by my solicitor Gerry Dunne who has been with me on this awful road for many many years now. I have been well supported by the media who follow my quest for justice and in particular Nicola Tallant and the Sunday World who have stood by me through the years and fought hard for justice for Noleen. I was relieved and excited to reach a stage in my studies recently where I knew I would be able to graduate in 2015 with a Bachelor's Degree in Social Science and I felt I had achieved the unachievable and I will post more on that nearer the time.

So yes, in all I feel I got somewhere in 2014, I feel I achieved something and I feel I did all I could to get justice for Noleen. Its not easy for me to say that because most of the time in the last 20 years I felt I had not done enough for her, in fact nothing I ever did for her ever felt enough, how could it?? How could I as a mother ever feel I had done enough to put right what they did to her?

I can already hear you saying that it wasn't up to me to make it right, that I was only a child too, but as a mother I have this huge need to make it right for her, and when I can't I torture myself and carry the huge burden of responsibility of trying to get justice for her.

So this year I have been able to feel that the burden is not so heavy because the police investigation along with the possibility of the public inquiry and the petition and the support from my solicitor and the Sunday world have eased my load and helped me to
feel that things are moving or happening at long last.

I must not forget Richard Boyd Barratt and Clare Daly and the support they also gave me which is second to none and remarkable, also Niall Collins has been in regular touch with my solicitor too.

But of course it wasn't all good, firstly the fact that the case was being looked at caused me a lot of trauma and distress, which haunted me daily, it was agonising and prolonged and it is still on going and not about to ease up anytime soon. Most days it was all I could do was to get out of bed and my studies went out the window causing me to have to cancel my graduation in the summer of 2014, this left me feeling very upset and disappointed and robbed all over again.

Simon was diagnosed with prostate cancer in September but had been having the tests for months and they were hanging over our heads, he is now waiting to have surgery so things are still worrying until he gets the all clear.

I would say that 2014 was probably the worse year in many years for trauma and distress and PTSD and nightmares and flashbacks and anxiety all due to the police investigation and other developments.  A lot of the time I felt as if I was dead inside and an empty shell, every time I thought things were settling down another part of the case jumped out at me or came back to haunt me. But I wasn't the only one haunted.

I knew that no matter what I was going through the men who abused me were going through more, the tables had now turned, they were the ones frightened of the knock on the door, or scared of the newspapers reporting on the crimes they committed and it was now them running scared, OK, so they were not in prison but they might as well have been because everyone now knew who they were and they were exposed in the Sunday World with their faces pixelated but easily identifiable.

It was reported in the media when they were brought in for questioning and it was also reported when there main ringleader of the paedophile ring was booted out of the sports club where he had been chairman for over 40 years, even two weeks ago a journalist knocked on his door and I am sure they will be knocking again very soon.

So, what's the moral of the story?? What can I say at the end of 2014?? Well, I can say that despite everything, the stress and the trauma, the awfulness of it all, I still survived, despite Simon being ill we soldiered on, despite not graduating I still managed to go back to my studies and to see to it that I will graduate this year.

But most importantly I think that despite the awful horrific childhood I had, a childhood I should NOT have survived I did survive, but not only did I survive I went on to learn to love and to be loved.

I went on and found the strength to fight and I finally feel that I was a good contender that I put up a good fight and that I took back some of my power. I am no longer that terrified little child that they controlled and ruled in my home and my school and my community.

No matter how this ends for now I feel like I didn't give up, I didn't take no for an answer and I went after them, I went after the men who abused me and destroyed me and who thought they had got away with it. I went after men whom I was terrified of as a child, men who controlled me, men who were sure of my silence and their secrets being kept, men who were pillars of the community, men who had the money to pay others for their silence too and men who were policemen and had good friends in tje police but nothing lasts forever and just when they might have began to believe that they finally got away with it, that they were home and dry I came after them and  for that I am proud of myself.

Even if they never go to prison I still feel like they are incarcerated in their minds, just like I used to be as a small child waiting for them to do what they did, now they are waiting for me.

As we go into 2015 I am no longer an abuse victim, I am a fighter and a survivor and I am also a wife and mother, I am a student and a friend, a pet owner and many more things.

I no longer allow abuse to define me, its now a small part of who I am, I am many things and I am sure in the future I will be many more.

So, my plans as we go into the new year??? Well,,,, my plan is to continue in the new year on the path I am on now, the path of seeing out the police investigation and praying that these major developments come to fruition. Then hopefully I will get the inquiry my case needs and deserves and I also intend on keeping up my campaign as usual, updating my Facebook page and I am now on twitter @cynthiaowen91 and I also intend to keep on, keeping on.

I have no intention whatsoever of giving up or giving in, if I do not get justice or the inquiry or any other avenues then I intend to name and shame my abusers publicly.

I intend on letting the world know who they are and where they live and what they did, one way or another the world will find out what really happened to myself and Noleen and my siblings. So, for now I am happy to wait for the slow wheels of justice to keep on turning but once those wheels stop I will be ready to launch my public campaign immediately and ready to name them all and what they did.

So my message for the monsters who abused me  as we go into 2015 is, one way or another I'm going to find a way to make sure the world knows who you are, however I do it, but it will be done, no more secrets or silence and no more lies.

Thank you everyone for your much appreciated support and a Happy New Year, heres to justice and recognition and acknowledgement for myself and my siblings and Noleen and John.


Saturday, 22 November 2014

Dessie Swords (Facebook 21 November 2014)

So, I log onto Facebook last night and some guy had put up a photo of Dessie Swords a deceased church clerk from Dalkey, who had been clerk to the church for 50 years.

Dessie Swords was one of the men who abused me, and was in some ways held up as a pillar of the community while in other ways local housewives warned thier children not to go to the church during the day when he was there and to stay away from 'Dirty Dessie'.

Dessie could be seen on a daily basis walking around the town in his church garb, approaching the young kids encouraging them to come to the church at 6pm where he would let them ring the church bell then sexually assault them while doing so.

He had been reported to the police and the parish priest, and he left many victims in his wake.

Some of these victims have spoken to my solicitor.

If you wanted to contact my solicitor in strict confidence his name is Gerry Dunne, Dublin 01-6628530. Or alternatively you can ring Dunlaoghaire Garda station and ask for Chief Superintendent Diarmuid O'Sullivan he also is aware of Swords background.

Or if you want to contact me about Swords or any other paedophile in Dalkey in confidence my email address is sindyowen@googlemail.com

I have seen other postings about Swords in the past and made the decision to say nothing, but no more lies and silence, I just couldnt stand by and watch him being held up as a pillar of the community again when the real truth is he was a prolific paedophile.


Tuesday, 18 November 2014

Panel Review have looked at 140 cases

Panel Review half way through!

Department of Justice and Equality
Garda Misconduct Allegations

Niall Collins (Limerick, Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
514. To ask the Minister for Justice and Equality the status of the independent review panel of complaints against An Garda SƭochƔna; the timeline for the completion of the review; the personnel currently on the review panel; the conflict of interest procedures on the panel; if the findings of the panel will be published; if a debate will be held on the report; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [41459/14]
Niall Collins (Limerick, Fianna Fail)


Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
517. To ask the Minister for Justice and Equality the timeframe for the completion of the independent review mechanism currently being conducted by the panel of barristers; the number of cases that have been completed to date; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [41519/14]


Niall Collins (Limerick, Fianna Fail)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
519. To ask the Minister for Justice and Equality the actions she will take to address cases similar to those currently being reviewed by the independent review mechanism when the review mechanism ceases to function; and if she will make a statement on the matter. [41521/14]


Clare Daly (Dublin North, United Left)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source
533. To ask the Minister for Justice and Equality the numbers of cases that have been reviewed by the review panel; if persons have been notified of the results; and the outcome or current status of their cases. [41946/14]

Frances Fitzgerald (Minister, Department of Justice and Equality; Dublin Mid West, Fine Gael)
Link to this: Individually | In context | Oireachtas source

I propose to take Questions Nos. 514, 517, 519 and 533 together.

The Deputies are referring to the mechanism established for the independent review of certain allegations of Garda misconduct, or inadequacies in the investigation of certain allegations, which have been made to me as Minister for Justice and Equality, or the Taoiseach, with a view to determining to what extent and in what manner further action may be required in each case. A panel consisting of two Senior and five Junior Counsel was established for the purpose. The counsel appointed to the panel, and who were all selected on the basis of their experience of the criminal justice system, are:
Senior Counsel: Conor Devally, Paul Greene.

Junior Counsel: Paul Carroll, John Fitzgerald, Tony McGillicuddy, SiobhÔn Ni ChúlachÔin, Karen O'Connor.

Appropriate steps have been taken to ensure that nothing arises which might in any way detract from the integrity of the review mechanism, including issues of conflict of interest. Arrangements have been put in place to ensure that if there is any conflict, or potential conflict, the conflicted counsel not only will not be involved in the particular complaint, but also will not be aware of which counsel is reviewing it. This is normal professional conduct and there are sufficient counsel on the Panel to ensure the practicality of this. Whatever steps are necessary will be taken to ensure there is no conflict of interest.


It was originally anticipated that the review would last some ten to twelve weeks. However, the availability of Counsel due to the operation of the Courts calendar together with the volume of complaints submitted means that this timeframe will be exceeded. As I already mentioned, it is important that nothing arises which might detract from the integrity of the review mechanism. It is therefore considered inappropriate to place a time constraint upon the working of the Panel, although they intend to conclude their work as soon is reasonably practicable.

I understand the panel have to date reviewed almost 140 cases and I expect recommendations to be submitted to me in due course. I will decide whether any further action is desirable and could practicably be taken in each case in light of the recommendations made by Counsel on the Panel, and each complainant will be notified accordingly.

While it would not be appropriate to publish individual recommendations, I will consider how best information on the outcome of this process could be made public.
While the independent review mechanism was established as a temporary measure, it was envisaged that there might be a need to consider the case for a continuing capacity to review further cases which may arise in the future. I have no doubt that the contents of the recommendations received from the Panel will inform how we deal with such issues once the independent review mechanism has concluded its work.

The Deputies will be aware however that, as part of the Government's comprehensive programme of reform in the areas of policing and justice in the State, I am bringing forward new legislation to amend the Garda Siochana Act 2005 to strengthen the remit and powers of GSOC, which is the statutory independent body set up under the Act with oversight functions in relation to the Garda Siochana. One of the legislative changes is to broaden the scope for me as Minister to refer any matter that gives rise to a concern to GSOC for investigation, and I would envisage GSOC as the primary mechanism for the future examination of allegations of this nature.

Getting married again, at Gretna Green!!!

ANOUNCEMENT: We just back from the most relaxing holiday ever in the middle of no where with no phone or internet and nothing to do but walk and study. I wanted to let you all know that Simon and I renewed our wedding vows at Gretna Green to celebrate 20 years of marriage and being together 28 years this month. I arranged it all as a surprise for Simon he knew nothing about it until we arrived at Gretna Green, he was delighted and said it was the best day of his life!!! Not only did we renew our vows we actually got married AGAIN under the old Scottish Laws and we were given a marriage certificate too! The ceremony we took part in was called 'Hand Fasting' where they bound both of our left hands together and we made promises to each other. We married at the old blacksmiths anvil which is world famous and is still the most romantic place in the world to marry and our ceremony consisted of just the two of us, the registrar and our dog Kane who they allowed in to be best man!!!! That's why he is wearing the tartan dickie bow in our photos!!! It was so very intimate and I was so happy I cried, I actually couldn't believe I pulled it off because we were so remote I had to drive 20 miles to get to a computer for phone numbers and to make the arrangements. I made the phone call to Gretna at 4.45pm and the shops were closing at 5pm that left me 15 minutes to find a dress, flowers and a shirt for Simon. Because the wedding was booked for the NEXT DAY! Now because it was a walking holiday I had no make up, no shoes (only a pair of leather boots and walking shoes) and neither of us brought any good clothes with us as we intended to be home every night snuggled up by the fire. On top of that, I had to pretend to Simon I was buying a dress for the Christmas party which this year is a masquerade ball, so I had ten minutes to find the dress fit it on, and try to find shoes to match that's why the dress is black lace because Simon thought I was buying it for our Christmas party! I didn't find any shoes so had to wear my winter boots. However our marriage ceremony was NOT about clothes, the dress, or my hair and make up, it was about two people being in love and wanting to marry each other again and to take time out in the awful world we live in to remember how much we mean to each other. Simon had brought a pair of black jeans, so I bought him a shirt to go with the jeans after sending him out of the shop pretending I was buying him a Christmas present. The shirt he is wearing in the photo was the only shirt in the shop and they didn't sell ties or dickie bows! Then I had to hide everything from him and get him to Gretna where I gave him the news. He is usually the romantic one between us, so he loved the whole idea, we were both very happy and it was a wonderful intimate day for us where I told him in my vows that nothing had ever beat us, and nothing ever will. OK we get knocked down but we are never down for long and one of us always picks the other one up. Simon picks me up with his enormous quiet strength and I pick Simon up with humor and make him laugh and smile. Nothing can part us or keep us down, nothing ever did and nothing ever will, not even cancer. I wasn't going to share this as it still feels so new, but Simon has been diagnosed with prostrate cancer, right bang slap in the middle of one of the worst years I have been having with my legal battle. But I decided to share to show others that no matter how hard life gets, no matter what life throws at you, you can still shut the world out if only for a day, and be happy or take time to love or to remember your strengths and your achievements; I'm also delighted to announce I WILL be graduating this year as I am nearly finished my Thesis and can safely say I will complete my degree on time. I was supposed to graduate last year, but the whole case blew up again and left me spinning and distraught, and feeling robbed and cheated when I had to ask for another year to complete my studies. I want those who thought they destroyed me to know that they haven't won, I can still achieve, I can still love and I can be loved right back by a brave wonderful man who now has his own battles to win as well as my battles too. But even though tomorrow may be awful, and the day after. We managed to stand still right in the middle of a huge storm and face the worse of it. And we are not done yet, we are about to face a different kind of battle, but that won't knock us down either. I want those who abused me to know, especially my parents and my siblings and my old teachers at primary school. And the pedophile ring in Dalkey, you did NOT steal everything, I am NOT just an abuse victim, I am a wife, a mother, a student, a friend, a fighter, a warrior, a survivor, I'm not and NEVER will be just your victim, you WILL not define me, I decide who and what I am, I always have, and I always will. Tomorrow probably will be tough, and the day after, just like many days before, I have been to hell and back a thousand times over, no doubt I will go back again a thousand times more, but even in hell I can fight and win, or take the time to look around me, and create my own destiny. I just wanted to share with you all that there is love out there, that we can find love no matter what we have been through, we are lovable, we can love and be loved, we can achieve, we can fight, and we can overcome, maybe not today, maybe not tomorrow, but there is hope, you can shut the door, bolt the world out, and step out of the nightmare even for a day. Despite the fact our car broke down on the way home and it took ten hours to complete what should have been a four hour journey I smiled all the way home even though we were tired and cold nothing could steal our joy. Even though we return to face the real world this week of hospital appointments and decisions to make. I feel a strange sense of calm and peace and strength, a feeling of that whatever happens we will be OK. I never really talk about this either how I believe in God, and recently things were so very tough that all I knew to do was to go to God and pray, pray for strength and courage, pray for the ability to carry on my battle in Ireland because I can't give up now, though it is tempting of course, and I was riddled with guilt as I tried to support Simon through the maze of tests etc and apply myself to the legal battle too. I felt I should have been more focused for Simon, instead of barely getting through each day. The legal battle is so very hard on its own, so to to have cancer to deal with on top of it is unbearably hard on both of us. So I went to God and I prayed for his guidance and strength and for peace, I was so troubled I desperately needed the gift of peace, if you have peace, you have everything, but I also needed to have courage and strength, it is not easy to hold onto peace, courage and strength, and that's why I want to share. To offer hope if only for today, before the real world knocks on my door again tomorrow, but for today I feel strong and at peace, and in my world and with what I am facing and coping with day to day, that is a miracle. I have been blessed with the miracle of faith and hope and courage and strength and joy. And I have been blessed with love from a wonderful strong honest reliable man who still doesn't ask any thing of me or expect me to give up on Noleen or my siblings or to give up fighting for myself, he still wants me to battle on against injustice and betrayal and when I ask him why, he replies 'because it is the right thing to do' Even when his own health is at risk he still encourages me to fight on, against the injustices and betrayals I have suffered because its the right thing to do. And with that kind of love and support is it any wonder I feel at peace, and feel that no matter what we will both be OK? I am truly blessed.

Friday, 15 August 2014

Review of Garda Files

Copy and paste this link: http://www.irishexaminer.com/ireland/review-of-garda-files-stalls-mccabe-inquiry-279052.html#.U-jq1akjYIA.facebook

Friday, 1 August 2014

Update August 2014

UPDATE AUGUST 2014 Things have been moving along nicely but slowly I met with the police in June and was happy with how things are progressing . I am satisfied that they are doing everything they can to secure convictions and that they are doing things properly now. One of the men from The Sorrento Six was removed from the large sports club he was involved in, while another one was sacked from his job and another one had to stop drinking in the pub he drank in daily for 40 years. The main ringleader of the Sorrento Six suffered a stroke and is in hospital due to the pressure of the investigation, he was questioned two times recently by the police and is beginning to fold now under the strain. The tables have well and truly turned now and they are no longer in control and have no power within the police force because a new team have come in and they are making sure everything is done properly, nothing is now going thier way, where once they called the shots, now I do, and now the shoe is on the other foot. I am waiting to hear if there will be an inquiry into my case and I am also in correspondence with GSOC, so along with the possibility of convictions there are many irons in the fire, and I am confident that the identity of the men will be known soon and that big things are on the horizon. In the meantime I am trying to study for my degree and to take breaks where I can if I'm lucky enough not to be weighed down with everything alongside trying to live a normal life which of course is not always possible as I am often brought to my knees with the weight of it all and my mind become overwhelmed with it all and I can be incapable of getting through the day or of leading any kind of existence. But onward and upwards and hoping for an outcome of some sort after the long summer when I hope to get some Positive news in of which I will update you all again. Once again thanks to everyone for thier support, I really could not do this without you all!

Friday, 30 May 2014

Update 30 May 2014 and how you can help

UPDATE 30th May 2014: Just before I shut down the facebook page I am in a position to be able to say that things are proceeding nicely. Investigations are ongoing and will be for a while yet, however I am happy with how things are proceeding and will be meeting with the police in the not too distant future and can confirm that papers will be going to the DPP. Please continue to email Frances Fitzgerald and demand she opens an inquiry into my case, remember six men are still living in Dalkey who abused me, one of them is still involved in a local sports club that has over 200 children in it, another man has recently began to drink in pubs in Dunlaoghaire so this problem has widened out to pose a risk in another town. These men are on YOUR streets, watching YOUR kids, one of them is a taxi driver, another a gardener, your children are at risk. Email Frances Fitzgerald (Minister for Justice) and demand something is done questions will have to be answered, how does a man who sexually abused me and others get to be openly involved in a club with 200 kids??? Despite him being interviewed by police only weeks ago, and in 2005, and yet he has been involved in this club for over 40 years, who is going to take responsibility for any other victims that COULD have been saved?? Email info@justice.ie APPEAL: I am once again appealing for any victim of a paedophile ring in Dalkey or Dunlaoghaire to contact my solicitor Gerry Dunne in total confidence you can specify to him that contact is in confidence and he is not allowed to pass on information that you give, email him on info@obriendunne.com. Alternatively you can contact Chief Supt Diarmuid Sullivan at Dunlaoghaire Garda Station if you want to discuss being a victim of abuse particularly if you suspect your were abused by one of the men who abused me even if they are now dead. Please continue to read and share my blog which I will update regularly . Thank you to everyone who supported me and I will try to update you all as soon as I have any more news. Please do not PM or Inbox me on this page as I will not receive it from 30th May 2014.

Tuesday, 29 April 2014

Sorrento Six Interviewed

Copy and paste this link: www.independent.ie/irish-news/exgardai-are-quizzed-over-baby-murder-30180293.html">

Sunday, 19 January 2014

Information on my case from ukpaedos-exposed.com

THIS IS FROM THE WEBSITE http://ukpaedos-exposed.com/uk-child-abusers-named-and-shamed/facts-and-stats-on-child-abuse/its-time-to-tell-waiting-decades-to-break-the-silence/how-one-woman-has-found-the-strength-to-fight-for-justice/ 

  How one woman has found the strenght to fight for justice. How one woman has found the strength to fight for justiceThis is a true story about a girl suffering sexual abuse at the hands of her parents and “others” in Ireland in the 1970′s. Cynthia Owen grew up in Ireland, went to the local convent school, said her prayers and took her first communion with all the other girls in her class. But behind the faƧade of respectability lurked a hideous reality. Cynthia was just eight years old when she was first sexually abused and raped by her father amongst others At 11 years old, Cynthia was drugged and made pregnant by her father, when the baby was born Cynthia watched in horror as her own mother murdered the tiny infant, named Noleen, by repeatedly stabbing her with a knitting needle. Cynthia’s mother then wrapped the baby girl in a plastic bag, dumped her in an alleyway and made her daughter go back to school and pretend nothing had ever happened. Her parents even sold her repeatedly to a local paedophile ring of which 3 members were local police officers, one of these officers was present on the night of the murder and worked on her murder case but has never been brought to justice After enduring many more years of rape and violence, Cynthia came forward and reported her abuse and Noleen’s death. Six of the alleged ring are still alive and living in communities, but we cannot identify them for legal reasons. One is working directly with children. Another works as a gardener, while the other two masquerade as respectable pensioners. A further member of the ‘ring’ is a taxi driver who regularly ferries children in his car and the last is a former council worker and avid church goer. All are accused of buying children for ritualistic sex that allegedly occurred in a number of properties in the Dalkey area over a prolonged period of time. Her childhood was a brutal hell, with sexual abuse and vile secrets as common, ordinary and everyday as the love and security found in most families Cynthia Owen, now 51, was routinely raped by her father, ­sexually abused by her mother, and drugged with tranquillisers so a group of strangers could have sex with her. And throughout all these horrors, she was just a child. In this appalling ­catalogue, there is one event which stands out for Cynthia and which she waited 34 years to prove. Cynthia had a baby when she was 11. But she claims her mother stabbed the newborn girl to death with a knitting needle, dumped the body in a lane, and told Cynthia to forget it ever happened. Nobody will believe you, she taunted Cynthia. Youre mad. Youre a liar. That Cynthia has been able to carve out a stable and loving life for herself as an adult is remarkable, given these beginnings. But that is exactly what she has done, with a long marriage and a grown-up son to her credit. Not that its been easy, given the terrible ghosts of her past. For most of the time it feels as if my son and husband are living in the past with me, she says, but we try hard to maintain a normal home life. I protect my son from the details of my childhood, but its hard. Cynthia was so profoundly traumatised it took her more than 20 years to go to the police and it was 12 more years before the inquest into her baby daughters death took place, in 2007. The jury unanimously named Cynthia as the mother of murdered baby Noleen, who was born on April 4, 1973 in Dalkey, South Dublin, and stabbed to death the same day. Excerpts from my book "Living with Evil" written by Cynthia Owen. I staggered out of the inquest feeling elated and emotionally battered, Cynthia recalls. I had finally proved I had a baby when I was 11 who was murdered, but I wasnt sure Id got justice for Noleen.Cynthia felt cheated because her mother, Josie Murphy, had died before justice was finally done. She died laughing at me. She never served a day behind bars and nor did my father Peter Murphy, who died in 2008. And there are other men still alive out there who abused me but who have never been ­convicted so my victory was bitter-sweet.Cynthia was one of nine ­children raised in a two-bedroom council house.She went to ­convent school, and her council worker father sat in church when she took her First Holy Communion. But behind closed doors ­Cynthia was suffering ­unimaginable abuse, which started around the time she was seven. Her father raped her almost daily, even at Christmas as her siblings played downstairs. I thought that it was what all daddies did, she says, and when I complained to my mum, she said he was just rolling round drunk in the bed. The evil didnt stop there, and soon Cynthias mother was ­sexually abusing her too. There was no escape, says Cynthia. I lived like a zombie, and spent my days trying to block out the abuse. My nerves were always jangling, I was so afraid. Cynthias mother Josie drank all night and slept all day, ­insisting the house be kept in darkness with black blankets pinned over the windows. The house was filthy and cold, and Cynthia was always dirty and lice-ridden. 

The neglect alone was ­shocking, says Cynthia. 

My parents spent all their money on cigarettes and alcohol. When Cynthia was 10, the abuse ­escalated. Her mother drugged her with Valium then took her to a building in the middle of the night. Inside were a crowd of men, ­including her father, all dressed in black cloaks. I was subjected to what I now know was ritual abuse, she says. 

I was confused because of the drugs but it happened once a month, and money changed hands. The abuse had an inevitable consequence Cynthia was almost 11 when she started feeling ill. I complained to my mum about funny feelings in my stomach and she coldly replied that I was ­having a baby, that it was going to be a freak, and that I was to say nothing. I was so terrified, I obeyed her, and tried to hide my bump under a smock coat. Cynthia gave birth at home on the bedroom floor at 4 Whites Villas, now dubbed the Dalkey House of Horrors, to a baby she called Noleen.

 Both parents looked on, then argued about who was going to kill the baby. In the end Cynthia claims it was Josie who stabbed the newborn girl 40 times with a knitting needle. She thought my dad was the babys father, says Cynthia, but Noleen could have been fathered by any of the men abusing me at that time. Cynthia blacked out after ­giving birth, but later her ­mother dragged her out to dump the baby in a plastic bag in nearby Dun Laoghaire. Two schoolboys discovered the body the next day, and there was a TV appeal for information. The following years were a nightmare for Owen. 

The abuse continued. She says she got pregnant again at 15 and gave birth prematurely to a stillborn baby. She began drinking heavily. “My mother was evil,” says Owen. “I also think she was mentally ill. 

She would pit all of us children against each other and single some out as her favourites. She decided I was the baddest all. I think it’s because I used to question why she had 60 cigarettes a day while we went without socks and toothbrushes. 

Also, I was the only child that looked like her. I had her red hair and green eyes, while all the other children were dark. I don’t know if that was some kind of trigger.” Cynthia was ordered to say nothing and go back to school and the murder remained unsolved.

 There was no let-up in the abuse, however, and Cynthia eventually left the ­family home at 19. She moved away, ­determined to turn her back on the evils of her past. Cynthia met and married Simon, the man she calls her saviour, and proudly raised her son Christopher*, who is now 22 years old. She was haunted by her childhood ­experiences and was determined to see justice done, but ­Cynthia was in her 30s before she felt strong enough to go to the police.

 I needed my parents and the other paedophiles to pay for their crimes, she says. I couldnt let them get away with it for any longer. A complicated legal battle followed, with the authorities refusing to prosecute because of a lack of evidence, and Cynthia accusing the police of a cover-up. The ghosts of their past haunted Cynthias siblings too. 

Her younger brother Martin hanged himself at the age of 27, and her brother Michael died in mysterious circumstances at 29. Theresa, 33, who was raised as Cynthias sister but was actually her niece, hanged herself too, leaving behind a suicide note detailing the sexual abuse she and Michael had suffered at the hands of their father. 

 Cynthias new book, Living With Evil, tells the shocking story of her childhood, and she hopes it will force the authorities to re-examine her case. 

 She explains: I am not a scared little girl any more. I am very proud of what I have achieved, and I will not stop until all my abusers are behind bars. She is proud of her husband and son, but says family life is not easy. I am eaten up with guilt for trying to get justice for Noleen I feel my son and husband suffer for it, but they have never asked me to stop my legal battle. “What happened robbed us of a normal life. 

My husband was only 21 when I met him and I had Christopher already. Within a year of us being together I was sterilised because I couldnt cope, emotionally, with having more children. “From then on my husband knew he would never have children if he stayed with me, and I feel guilty that I took that away from him. Cynthia, who has a successfully completed a university course but is unable to work because of post-traumatic stress and depression, adds: 


The day-to-day can be a struggle, but I have built a safe and stable family life which is helping me to heal and to cope. February 2007 Cynthia Owen mother of baby girl: verdict A jury in an inquest into the death of a baby girl almost 34 years ago has reached a unanimous verdict that the child was that of Cynthia Owen. The jury also found that the place of death was a house at White’s Villas in Dalkey on 4 April 1973. The jury cannot apportion blame to any person due to the Coroners Act of 1962 and so returned an open verdict. T

he infant died as a result of shock and haemorrage due to multiple stab wounds. The Coroner Dr Kieran Geraghty thanked the jury for their deliberations. He then called Cynthia Owen into the witness box and she broke down as the verdict was announced. She was supported by her husband Simon as she told the court that she had given her child the name Noleen. 

The coroner then formally recorded that Noleen Murphy was the infant found stabbed to death 34 years ago. A number of members of the jury cried as their verdict was formally read out. Earlier the Dublin County Coroner, Dr Kieran Geraghty, told the jury that this inquest was not a criminal trial and he said the level of proof required for an inquest jury to bring in a verdict was not the same as ‘beyond reasonable doubt’ in a criminal trial. The jury had been asked to determine whether ‘on the balance of probabilities’, the mother of the infant is Cynthia Owen, who alleges she was the victim of repeated sexual abuse as a child. It took the jury of six men and six women less than five hours to reach the unanimous verdict.

Monday, 4 February 2013

Social Services

Social services have been involved in my family since 1972, they may have been involved before that but I can only find records that go back to house visits in October 1972, I was pregnant then aged 10 and a half years old. 

We had a further 2 house visits at the time, a pyschiatrist recommended that my brother (who sexually abused 4 of my siblings and myself) but who would end up with 10 different abuse allegations  against him was a danger to the community and the psychiatrist ordered he be placed in a remand school, yet no one seemed to think about our danger?

At this time, I was pregnant, my four siblings were all below the age of 8, two of them only babies, the four of these siblings could have been spared being abused, three of them are now dead.  Noleen's life could have been saved, and I would not have had to witness her murder or go on to become pregnant again.

My brother came out of the institution he was placed in, and carried on abusing all 5 of us, in the Inquest older sisters said they knew about this, that they openly discussed it with my mother (she told them our brother was abusing the younger children) and STILL no one helped us.

From 1955 to 1980, 10 children from my family home went to Loreto Abbey in Dalkey, all 10 of us, were lice ridden, filthy, smelled and displayed severe behaviour symptons, we hardly ever turned up at school, regularly fell asleep in class, and all struggled to learn.

My older siblings ran away often, went missing for weeks on end, were in regular trouble with the police and STILL no one saved us.

Friday, 25 January 2013

Information on the Review Patrick Gageby did into my files

Once Noleen was identified in the Inquest in 2007, the then Minister for Justice Michael McDowell ordered a review into the police files, because of course, questions had to be asked how a baby could be murdered in my family home, and no one ever be brought to justice.

My solicitor and I had been corresponding with the Department of Justice and with Michael McDowell, he knew we wanted a public inquiry into the case, he knew I was accusing three retired police officers of sexually abusing me and covering up the murder, to hide the fact that they could have been Noleens father, we had handed in a petition from friends, neighbours and supporters  with 2,000 signatures asking for a public inquiry but instead he commissioned Patrick Gageby to look at the police records.

Gageby was biased towards abuse victims as the previous article shows, we were never told why he was chosen, because we would have preferred at least three independent people to look at the files, not one biased barrister who had in it for abuse victims, my solicitor tried to draw up terms of reference for the review but McDowell only agreed to some of them.

Gageby refused to meet with me, I found this absolutely amazing, seeing as I was the victim but instead he got all his information from the police, his tone throughout the review was very harsh towards me, as if he personally knew me and hated me, he treated me more like a convict, he made many mistakes in the review, relied on his own personal opinion, and the bias information given to him by the police, who were friends with the men who abused me and with my father.

He did criticize the police for losing all the items at the scene, but said  public inquiry
wouldn't find them, but on the whole, the review was made up of biases against me, it called me a "complainer" and said I was conducting a witch hunt against innocent men, who by the way were all arrested on suspicion of abusing me, and he said I was trying to bring down "powerful men" this confused me as some of the men who abused me did menial jobs, and given I was from Dalkey, where actors, politicians, lawyers, doctors, and writers lived. I was at a loss as to how I would have "picked" the men I did or accused the men I did, because if I was looking for attention or to bring down powerful men, I had the cream of the crop to choose from, but instead accused men who did mundane everyday jobs, grant it, some of them were business owners, or police officers, but they were not as rich or powerful as some of the men in Dalkey I could have falsely accused if I was making this up. If I was making it up, why was I never charged with wasting police time, and why did the DPP look at the file seven times? And why did the Inquest identify Noleen as being my daughter?

It makes my blood boil when victims are accused of looking for attention when they make abuse allegations, its not and never is, good or even bad attention when a victim alleges they have been sexually abused, its shameful, and embarrassing and awful.  I had to sit through all the police statements I had made being read out at the Inquest, in front of approximately 100 people, I had never talked to my husband about the sexual abuse, or told him what they did to me. It was excruciating for me to have to sit on the stand, and have my husband and friends and strangers hear about the sex acts carried out on my body. And then have my fathers  barrister accuse me of lying or looking for attention, its not the sort of attention any human being would want or seek, unless they were actual victims trying to put right a huge injustice. At the Inquest 4 of my sisters admitted they had been abused in my family home, and my brothers Martin and Michael and sister Theresa before they died all admitted being abused, and all of my four sisters at the Inquest said that Martin, Michael and Theresa and myself had complained to them over the years that we had been sexually abused, so that including me brought the total to 8 children in my family home saying they had been abused. And yet my father still wasn't convicted.

Gageby wrote one and a half sentences in his review about the Inquest, and gave no weight to the fact that an independent jury of 12 witnesses had unanimously identified Noleen, in other words he completely ignored the fact that she had been identified as my daughter.  He recommended that no more money be spent on my case, which cut me to the core, and said that nothing further could come of a public inquiry.

Since that day, when the review was published, (September 2007) every other politician has stood by this review and held it up against me and said that the review was final, but despite this in November 2007, the police without my knowledge or prompting, opened the case again and sent another file to the DPP to try to secure prosecutions, this confused me again as it wasn't what Gageby recommended.

In the UK a similar review done in the North Wales Inquiry, by Ronald Waterhouse QC in 2000, has now been put under investigation, when it came out that the judge leading the inquiry was given false information by the police, and the government in the UK are calling for victims to come forward. And David Cameron ordered a "review into the review"  but in Ireland, a biased, review full of errors, is apparently rock solid and stands, despite a baby being found dead, stabbed to death 40 times, and the mother of that baby, being able to give eye witness testimony to that murder and identify the fathers identity and the police officers who covered up her murder.

Patrick Gageby

Top barrister calls for 15-year limit on sex abuse trials

Monday, May 30, 2005

By John Breslin
A STATUTE of limitations should be placed on criminal proceedings taken against those accused of sexual abuse, one of the country’s leading defence barristers told a conference this weekend.

Patrick Gageby, who has defended individuals accused of sex crimes sometimes decades old, said it may be time for the Government to step in and draw a line in the sand.

Mr Gageby suggested a limit of 15 years, adding that all civil cases are subject to time limits, except ironically those relating to claims of sexual abuse.

Speaking at the National Prosecutors Conference, the defence barrister said there were inherent dangers in old cases, where the key witnesses have inaccurate, faded, changed or intruded memories and where there was little additional or corroborating evidence.

In too many cases, a jury trial can turn in to a "pure beauty contest."

"Who do you like more, who's the more attractive? Who exactly is telling the truth? It comes down to body movements, gestures and the like," Mr Gageby said.

Trials often descend into desperate searches for collateral information, such as the colour of paint, whether a bicycle was in a yard or whether a school was open that year.

Mr Gageby cited a number of cases one dating back to 1951, where the accused was in his 70s and the complainant in his 50s. The jury had to decide events that happened in a closed room 50 years ago.

In another trial, there was much discussion over when Dana won the Eurovision Song Contest after it was initially claimed the assault took place some time between 1964 and 1970.

While the higher courts have consistently ruled it was up to the trial judge to decide if a case was proceeding fairly, there was little jurisprudence over when to intervene to protect an accused from an unfair trial, Mr Gageby said.

On the plus, side, there are high standards within the prosecution service and the gardaĆ­, a strong commitment from all to secure a fair trial and the common sense of juries.

The barrister reserved his most trenchant criticism for the media and what he described as the "large industry abroad" of counsellors and psychologists.

The media is "wholly uncritical" of the redress and compensation system for victims of institutional abuse and there is almost "uncritical" acceptance of everything an alleged victim says.

Mr Gageby said he had never come across a psychological report that has found any difficulty with any person who has made a complaint. All the reports authors seem to assume the complainant is telling the truth, he said.

My Parents

Both of my parents are now dead, my mother died in August 2006, only a few months before Noleen was identified, in the Coroners court and my father died in December 2008, he attended the Inquest and sat laughing at me, he refused to give evidence saying he was ill, and did not turn up on the final day to hear Noleen being identified as my daughter.

Within weeks of the verdict at the Inquest my father took out a high court case against the coroner, claiming that the Coroners verdict was wrong, however the Coroner didnt identify Noleen a jury of 6 men and 6 women did, but regardless my father ploughed ahead with his case, this cut me to the core, the arrogance of the man, the fact that the only court action going on in Ireland for me or my daughter was from the paedophile who had abused me and the man who might be Noleens father.

But both my parents knew they were untouchable, they were arrested for ONE DAY, on 7th June 1995 and released without charge, they had too much on the cops who had abused me, and they knew they would never be convicted, if they ever were put on a stand they had too much to tell, too many other paedophiles to bring down with them.

From 1995 to 2005, through that whole time my father never hired a lawyer, but the day after my allegations came out in the media that I had been sexually abused by three retired police officers, my father gave an interview to a newspaper to say he was going to sue me, that he was hiring a lawyer.

At the Inquest he had hired a full legal team, solicitor, lawyer, and barrister, not only for him, but for three of my sisters as well, the Inquest went on for four and a half days, his fee's would have ran into anywhere between 30-50,000, and yet he was a retired corporation worker who drank 7 nights a week and smoked 60 cigarettes a day.

When he died, he left my 3 sisters and a brother 20,000 euro each, that was 100,000 euro, I had strong suspicions he was being "paid" to be kept quiet, and so were some of my siblings, and that all of their legal fee's were being paid for them.

My 3 oldest sisters, and my brother, had always hated my father, when we were growing up, they would never sit in the same room with him, when they left home, if they came back to visit, they would always try to visit when he was out, he never spoke to any of them, and he was very hostile towards all of them.

My 3 oldest sisters all gave police statements saying that they had been abused in our family home and that their four youngest siblings had been too, two of them admitted on the stand at the Inquest that the younger children were constantly complaining about being sexually abused, and that they did nothing to help us or rescue us.

But then went on to give newspaper interviews calling us liar, and yet, the police didn't take any action against them for this, on the one hand giving police statements backing up the abuse, but on the other hand publicly calling us liars. Then they turn up at the Inquest WITH my father and support him, the change in them was too radical, and knowing them the way I do, only money could have been what changed their mind.

A newspaper ran an article asking where they all got the money for their legal fees, and where did my father get the 100,000 euro to leave in his will, but the paper was immediately threatened with a law suit if they ever printed anything like that again???

My father died before the High Court case was heard, in March 2010, but my sisters continued with it, who paid their fee's? They were unemployed? The outcome was that my sister agreed to drop the case (she hadn't a leg to stand on anyway, because there was no way she would have had the decision overturned) if the Coroner agreed to make a statement saying he wasn't implicating her in Noleens murder, that in effect meant she was now admitting Noleen was my daughter and had been murdered in our home, only she wanted her name cleared.

All of this destroyed me, that Noleen could be treated like this, beyond what they had done to her, that even my sisters could taunt me and Noleen and call us liars, that my father was behind this even though he was dead, I continually asked myself what kind of Country would allow this to happen, that even when I have fought for so many years to get Noleens inquest up and running, within weeks my abuser snatches it from my hands and begins to abuse me all over again using the legal system to do so.


I put it to the gardai that my father was being paid "bribe" money and asked them to investigate who was paying his legal fee's but they said that was a private matter, even though the Criminal Assets Bureau can investigate solicitors if they think that someone is committing fraud, and surely if a retired member of the gardai was paying my father to stay quiet about his involvement in child rape and murder, that IS a criminal matter,  but my father was untouchable, no one could touch the man, he had way too much on other people and it was that, and that alone, that kept him and my mother free.